This is one of the most beloved local bands on the scene.” - Harold Garland

— The Local Overload Show

Meet the band

Problem with Polly is:

Ben Spencer- lead vocals/guitar

Scott Parrott- lead guitar/vocals

Kurt Husselman- bass

Aaron Smock- drums


Problem with Polly is an award-winning original rock band from Indianapolis, Indiana. Formed in 2016, PWP can be heard on a growing list of radio stations around the world.  

Their self-titled debut release has 10 songs, featuring fan favorites “Thumbs on the Trigger” and “Dead Man’s Face”.  

"Rages", also from their first album, was ranked #1 on Australian radio in March 2023.  

Problem with Polly has played all over Indiana and Kentucky, amassing a diehard group of local fans, the #pwpfamily, and has opened for national touring acts like Blacktop Mojo.  

"Light and Dark" is PWP's second album, released in July 2023.  

Thank you for listening to Problem with Polly on all music platforms.


Press photos

Social Links



Apple Music




PWP Live

Contact PWP

Previous events